CITIZENS, ALIENS AND OTHERS

‘A thousand years scarce serve to form a State. An hour may lay it in dust. (Byron)

          Citizens are members optimo jure, while aliens stand on lower level in the scale of legal rights. (Salmond).

          The Amending Act of 2019, notified on 12.12.2019, has witnessed across the length and breadth of India varied reactions from all those treading Indian Territory, be it as citizens, aliens or others. There is apparently a politically spearheaded series of street protests, as it always happen in the context of street violence, euphemistically called ‘street protests’. As usual, the campuses of academia also registered their fuming and flaming presence, buttressed by the disguised voices and invisible ‘pats’, in the political bandwagon of the protestors. The street protests symbolize the tryst of jurisprudence with other social sciences in the context of conflict resolution mechanisms. In such trysts the jurisprudence and all that it symbolizes is always left stranded in the streets, mauled and marauded and literally in a bleeding condition. Street protests also indicate dilution and erosion of the sacrosanct principles which constitutes the foundation of each and every institution, which any civilized society evolves over a period of ‘thousand years’ for the well being and development of the society. The dilution and erosion of all principles of constitutionality and democracy threaten to lay the celebrated ‘Leviathan’ in dust in one hour. The more street protests turn violent and louder, the deeper the rot and rust that seeps in the foundations of the institutions that govern the society.

          We are a numerically oversized democracy of multiple shades and multiple hues. The institutions which govern the life of an individual from cradle to grave, include our education system, operating through the crowded campuses of the Schools, Colleges and Universities. These institutions include the multi-coloured and overarching canopy of culture, holding within its folds multiple values and multiple mindsets, often moulded by unfiltered mediums of freshly-sprouted literature, off-the-shelf arts and ever-simmering politics. These institutions are predominantly controlled by our over-stressed judiciary, our nonchalant executive and our usually ‘numerically-disabled’ and ‘vote-bank over-conscious’ legislature. The resultant anarchy is celebrated, amidst the unbearable heavy weights of multiple interests, as ‘freedom’ under the well-orchestrated clout of political ideologues with deep pockets. Who are these string-holder ideologues, making their protégé  violently protest in the streets ? This existential question is seldom asked, much less answered. In such self-created anarchy due to numerically disabled parliaments, the meaty expression ‘freedom’  is used as a bait to trap the ‘fish’, most innocent segments of citizenry, for being roasted or fried as per political menus of these ideologues – socially and financially empowered clan of self-proclaimed intellectuals. Thus through the means and methods of street protests, the disguised predators and pirates of ‘power grubs’ in the political jungles of oversized democracy, politically legitimize the ‘fouls and flaws’ of their ruthless power games, while remaining technically hidden from the glare of the sentinel on the qui vive.

          The Citizenship Act, 1955, was originally notified on 30.12.1955. However, it was amended thrice, inter alia, on 28.06.2005 by the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2005. The amendment of 2005 introduced the concept of Overseas Citizen of India. Thus Section 7-A to Section 7-D, were added to Citizenship Act, 1955.

          As per 2019 Act, there are following five modes for acquisition of status of citizens of India:-

  • By Birth (Section 3)
  • By descent (Section 4)
  • By registration (Section 5)
  • By naturalization (Section 6)
  • By Incorporation of Territory (Section 7)

The aforesaid Sections inserted are kept intact by the Amendment Act, 2019. Only Section 6-B, 7-D and Section 18 are amended besides amendment of Section 2. Before glancing at the amended provisions, we need to bear in mind the constitutional philosophy and concepts.

          In order to understand the meaning of the expression citizen, in the context of Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019, one needs to understand the meanings of the words ‘Foreigner’, ‘National’, ‘Migrant’, ‘Illegal Migrant’ and ‘Resident’ (Ordinary resident or Permanent Resident).

The word ‘Foreigner’ is defined, in the ‘Foreigner’s Act, 1946.

The word ‘Nationality’ does not mean citizenship as even juristic persons can wear the tag of nationality even though they are not citizens. However, citizens are certainly an integral part of nationality.

However, a migrant is a person who migrates to India. Migration is voluntarily moving to India but not for specific purpose or for a limited period of time. Migration does not mean change of domicile in international law. Intention of permanent residence is not necessarily ingredient to constitute migration under Article 6 of the Constitution.

‘Illegal Migrant’ has been defined in Section 2(b), the said definition reads as under:-  

Section 2(b) “illegal migrant” means a foreigner who has entered into India—

(i) without a valid passport or other travel documents and such other document or authority as may be prescribed by or under any law in that behalf; or

(ii) with a valid passport or other travel documents and such other document or authority as may be prescribed by or under any law in that behalf but remains therein beyond the permitted period of time

Another concept relevant in the matter is Domicile. Mere residence of a person does not define his Domicile. Domicile is determined on the basis of following two grounds:-

  • The person’s fixed habitation.
  • Such person’s present intention of not moving therefrom.

          Domicile acquired by a person by his birth is called Domicile by birth, which continues until a person acquires a new Domicile, animo et facto. 

The word ‘Resident’ (ordinary or permanent resident) is analogous to the concept of domicile as contemplated in Article 5 of Constitution of India. Article 5 to Article 11 of Constitution of India are also relevant in the context of the constitutional scheme of citizenship.

The distinction between nationality and citizenship was considered at length by Hon’ble Supreme Court in AIR 1963 SC 1811, The State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. and Ors. vs. The Commercial Tax Officer, Visakhapatnam and Ors. The relevant dicta of Hon’ble Bench read as under:-

72. The operatives are regarded as the ‘brain’ of the corporation and where the brain functions the corporation is held to function. During times of peace a corporation may own property, do business because the Municipal law expressly permits that all this can be done and foreign corporations also obtain the benefit of such laws either because of provisions of the Municipal law or by a comity of nations. In times of was all this changes. The law of nationality is thus a law to determine the enemy character and not a law rec nationality either in a political or municipal sense. There may be some analogy between an individual and a corporation but as Mr. Vaughan Williams said 49 L.Q.R. 334 in an article which has been of great assistance to me, it is not necessary ‘to ride the analogy to death.’ The English Law was summed up by Mervyn Jones (British Nationality Law, Revised Edn.) :

 The Apex Court also approvingly noted that  Oppenheim in International Law, Lauterpacht Edition p. 642 n. 3 opined as under ;

“The nationality of corporations is mainly a matter of Private International Law, and considerations of Public policy have a decisive influence upon the attitude of every State with regard to it.”

“It is not for International Law but for Municipal Law to determine, who is, and who is not, to be considered a subject.”

The Apex Court also approvingly noted that  Hyde in his International Law Vol. 2 (2nd Edn.) p. 1066 also opines :

“Citizenship as distinct from nationality, is a creature solely of domestic law. It refers to rights which a State sees fit to confer upon certain individuals who are also its nationals.”

Be it democracy or any other form of Government, Citizen Vs. State, issue revolves around the questions of life, liberty and progress of the citizens. All other questions in the narrative of State Vs. Citizen are marginal in value, if not inconsequential. In the narrative of the Citizen Vs. State, the ‘others’ in addition to the aliens, are the unfriendly States, attempting to disrupt and defeat the nation building efforts. In this regard, the words of Kautilya an Arthasastra, being relevant are reproduced hereunder:-

“………….Life is a terrestrial opportunity for unfolding personality, rising to higher states, moving to fresh woods and reaching out to reality which makes out earthly journey a true fulfillment – not a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury signifying nothing, but a fine frenzy rolling between heaven and earth. The spirit of Man is at the root of Article 21. Absent liberty, other freedoms are frozen.”

          The organized street violence in the name of street protests is ‘sound and fury’ as described in the aforesaid opinion.

The Amending Act, 2019, contains the following Sections:-

2.       In the Citizenship Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the principal Act), in section 2, in sub-section (1), in clause (b), the following proviso stands inserted, namely:—

                    “Provided that any person belonging to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi or Christian community from Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan, who entered into India on or before the 31st day of December, 2014 and who has been exempted by the Central Government by or under clause (c) of sub-section (2) of section 3 of the Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920 or from the application of the provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 or any rule or order made thereunder, shall not be treated as illegal migrant for the purposes of this Act;”.

3.       After section 6A of the principal Act, the following section stands inserted, namely:—

                    ‘6B. (1) The Central Government or an authority specified by it in this behalf may, subject to such conditions, restrictions and manner as may be prescribed, on an application made in this behalf, grant a certificate of registration or certificate of naturalisation to a person referred to in the proviso to clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 2.

         (2) Subject to fulfilment of the conditions specified in section 5 or the qualifications for naturalisation under the provisions of the Third Schedule, a person granted the certificate of registration or certificate of naturalisation under sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be a citizen of India from the date of his entry into India.

           (3) On and from the date of commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019, any proceeding pending against a person under this section in respect of illegal migration or citizenship shall stand abated on conferment of citizenship to him:

                    Provided that such person shall not be disqualified for making application for citizenship under this section on the ground that the proceeding is pending against him and the Central Government or authority specified by it in this behalf shall not reject his application on that ground if he is otherwise found qualified for grant of citizenship under this section:

                   Provided further that the person who makes the application for citizenship under this section shall not be deprived of his rights and privileges to which he was entitled on the date of receipt of his application on the ground of making such application.

                    (4) Nothing in this section shall apply to tribal area of Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram or Tripura as included in the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution and the area covered under “The Inner Line” notified under the Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873.’.

4.       In section 7D of the principal Act,—

          (i) after clause (d), the following clause stands inserted, namely:—

          “(da) the Overseas Citizen of India Cardholder has violated any of the provisions of this Act or provisions of any other law for time being in force as may be specified by the Central Government in the notification published in the Official Gazette; or”;

(ii) after clause (f), the following proviso shall be inserted, namely:—

          “Provided that no order under this section shall be passed unless the Overseas Citizen of India Cardholder has been given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.”

5.       In section 18 of the principal Act, in sub-section (2), after clause (ee), the following clause stands inserted, namely:—

                    “(eei) the conditions, restrictions and manner for granting certificate of registration or certificate of naturalisation under sub-section (1) of section 6B;”.

6.       In the Third Schedule to the principal Act, in clause (d), the following proviso stands inserted, namely:—

          ‘Provided that for the person belonging to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi or Christian community in Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan, the aggregate period of residence or service of Government in India as required under this clause shall be read as “not less than five years” in place of “not less than eleven years”.-

The conceptual peregrinations on the subject compel us to avoid excessive legalism. In this regard, opinion of Mr. Justice Brandeis needs to be kept in mind. He said that:

“……….a lawyer, who has not studied economics and sociology, is apt to become a public enemy.”

Mr. Justice Cardozo went further, while holding that the law is always a jealous mistress; but now a days, said Caedozo; she has become “insatiable in her demands. Not brought within her ken, and so within the range sacrifice exacted of her votaries. Those who would earn her best rewards must make their knowledge as deep as the science and as broad and universal as the culture of their day.  She will not be satisfied with less.”

Justice Krishna Iyer’s described the said opinion of Justice Cardozo as Cardozian Kamasutra.

The amended Act, 2019, does not apparently curtail any right of the Indian Muslims, living in India. As regards the question of Muslim ‘illegal migrants’, the ground of persecution of a Muslim in the neighbouring Muslim Countries is not ex facie credible, by any stretch of imagination. If still any valid or credible material is available in the hands of so called ‘victims of discrimination’, amended law permits them to seek naturalization as a citizen through due process. Even in such factual scenario, having no shred of discriminatory policy, the misinformation is gaining ground in the politically-chlorinated waters and dark clouds of ignorance rule the roosts.

          Is it not a case of ‘gross political illiteracy’ on the part of the dramitis personae responsible for the large scale incidents of violence, arson besides politically engineered extermination of human life?

          Do the so called ideologues and string-pullers of politically anesthetized student community not deserve to be punished as murderers, arsonists and misanthropes?

          Nation needs tranquility for development. Misinformation and motivated street violence by raking up the religious sentiments of the vulnerable persons, without any valid justification, is not conducive to the development of the nation, especially in a multi-cultural and multi-religious society, which is sadly hosting 35% of illiterate adult population of the World. In this regard, wisdom of sages shows light in the political bewilderment, where Frankensteins, hiding as self-styled political leaders, are blatantly attempting to push our vibrant and grand democracy.   

A great sage, Rumi, expresses his wisdom through the following ecstatic phrase:-

‘Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and right doing there is a field, I’ll meet you there. When the soul lies down in that grass the World is too full to talk about’.

The amending Act, 2019, is a welcome step in the context of nation building exercise.

Hail India! Hail Constitution! Hail Democracy!

Maharashtra politics – Constitutional issues and challenges- Nocturnal Journey of Indian Institutions

Law, especially the branch of constitutional law, need to be read, grasped and construed with the maxim salus popli suprema lex at the hindsight. The said maxim signifies that the law is quintessentially for well being of the public as well being of public is its supreme object. The events, occurrences in the political clime of Maharashtra, while successfully installed, within the framework of the Constitution of India, do not at all stand, much less finally stand, on the pedestal of the aforesaid maxim. The event in Maharashtra, in the context of post-election formation of a Government, tosses up various existential questions regarding essence of democracy, which deserve due consideration in the judicially radiated constitutional light, inter alia, on the aforesaid maxim of salus popli suprema lex. While pondering over the warp and weft of the critical events, the following factual facets call for special consideration:-

(i) The alleged ‘intrusions’ by central government in the state politics through the deviant role of governor with respect to such facets which adversely impinge upon the sacrosanct principles of federalism.

(ii) The nocturnal journey of the supreme institutions, which form bedrock of our democracy, solely to validate, vindicate, over look, aid and even abet the existential crisis in democracy, as the same carry within its length and terrain dark waves of wild vagrancy, certainly unworthy of the constitutional obligations of these institutions constitutionally devised for glorification of democracy.

(iii) The confinement, of course wrongful, by use of force, even of the elected representatives by their respective party leaders, ostensibly to prevent ‘horse-trading’ is not only ugly blot on the integrity of the polity but indicative of dismally negative self assessment regarding character and credentials of the representative elected by the citizens on the basis of their self-proclaimed standards of probity and honesty.

(iv) Wanton transmuting of convention-based and transparent procedure of ‘floor test’ into  complex and dark curvatures in the nature of ‘water testing’ in power games, in full public view, including the watchful eyes of the institutionally celebrated sentinel on the que vive – Supreme Court of India.

(v) Sheer inability and helplessness of the people of India, at such critical hour of crisis, to fill the constitutional silence on the ideal patterns and combinations of power sharing in the multiparty patch-up of govt. with semantics and values of constitutionalism.

          With regard to the first question of ‘intrusions’ by the Central Government and silence on the part of the Courts, which will historically be read and treated as a anti-democratic pontification from the  Supreme pulpit, while the proverbially Rome was burning, the relevant aspects need to be unravelled.  

          With regard to the ‘intrusions’, real or unreal, emanating from central government, the constitutional scheme, which speaks of unity and not uniformity of States, besides bearing within its fold unequivocal reverence for the principles of federalism stood stressed and twisted, by Maharashtra episode. The Articles of Constitution need to be glanced to understand the nature and complexion of ‘intrusions’ by the Central Government in the federal status of Maharashtra.

          Article 1 of Constitution of India declares India as a Union of States. Apparently, it depicts federal character of the Union, as is constitutionally defined, as India i.e. Bharat.

          Constitution is not to be read literally and the substance of its Articles needs to be understood in a perspective, which subsumes the principles values and tenets described by the Constitutional Benches of Supreme Court, often through gilted words and phrases, such as, Constitutional morality, Constitutional limitations, Conscience of the Constitution, Soul of Constitution as well as Constitutional silences.

          The relevant Articles of Constitution which need to be quick-glanced at this stage, in the context of the constitutional issues and existential crisis underlying the present day Maharashtra political scenario, are Articles 168, 170, 172, 173, 175 of the Constitution of India. The same are reproduced for convenient reference;

168. Constitution of Legislatures in States:-

(1) For every State there shall be a Legislature which shall consist of the Governor, and

(a) in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Telangana, and Uttar Pradesh, two houses:

(b) in other States, one House.

(2) Where there are two Houses of the Legislature of a State, one shall be known as the Legislative Council and the other as the Legislative Assembly, and where there is only one House, it shall be known as the Legislative Assembly

170. Composition of the Legislative Assemblies

(1) Subject to the provisions of Article 333, the Legislative Assembly of each State shall consist of not more than five hundred, and not less than sixty, members chosen by direct election from territorial constituencies in the State

(2) For the purposes of clause (1), each State shall be divided into territorial constituencies in such manner that the ratio between the population of each constituency and the number of seats allotted to it shall, so far as practicable, be the same throughout the State.

Explanation:- In this clause, the expression “population” means the population as ascertained at the last preceding census of which the relevant figures have been published:

Provided that the reference in this Explanation to the last preceding census of which the relevant figures have been published shall, until the relevant figures for the first census taken after the year 2026 have been published, be construed as a reference to the 2001 census.

(3) Upon the completion of each census, the total number of seats in the Legislative Assembly of each State and the division of each State into territorial constituencies shall be readjusted by such authority and in such manner as Parliament may by law determine:

              Provided that such readjustment shall not affect representation in the Legislative Assembly until the dissolution of the then existing Assembly:

              Provided further that such readjustment shall take effect from such date as the President may, by order, specify until such readjustment takes effect, any election to the Legislative Assembly may be held on the basis of the territorial constituencies existing before such readjustment:

               Provided also that until the relevant figures for the first census taken after the year 2026 have been published, it shall not be necessary to readjust-

  • the total number of seats in the Legislative Assembly of each State as readjusted on the basis of the 1971 census; and
  • the division of such State into territorial constituencies as may be readjusted on the basis of the 2001, census, under this clause.

172. Duration of State Legislatures

(1)        Every Legislative Assembly of every State, unless sooner dissolved, shall continue for five years from the date appointed for its first meeting and no longer and the expiration of the said period of five years shall operate as a dissolution of the Assembly:

                          Provided that the said period may, while a Proclamation of Emergency is in operation, be extended by Parliament by law for a period not exceeding one year at a time and not extending in any case beyond a period of six months after the Proclamation has ceased to operate

(2)        The Legislative Council of a State shall not be subject to dissolution, but as nearly as possible one-third of the members thereof shall retire as soon as may be on the expiration of every second year in accordance with the provisions made in that behalf by Parliament by law.

173. Qualification for membership of the State Legislature-

A person shall not be qualified to be chosen to fill a seat in the Legislature of a State unless he-

(a)        is a citizen of India, and makes and subscribes before some person authorised in that behalf by the Election Commission an oath or affirmation according to the form set out for the purpose in the Third Schedule;

(b)        is, in the case of a seat in the Legislative Assembly, not less than twenty five years of age and in the case of a seat in the Legislative Council, not less than thirty years of age; and

(c)        possesses such other qualifications as may be prescribed in that behalf by or under any law made by Parliament

175. Right of Governor to address and send messages to the House or Houses

(1)        The Governor may address the Legislative Assembly or, in the case of a State having a Legislative Council, either House of the Legislature of the State, or both Houses assembled together, and may for that purpose require the attendance of members

(2)        The Governor may send messages to the House or Houses of the Legislature of the State, whether with respect to a Bill then pending in the Legislature or otherwise, and a House to which any message is so sent shall with all convenient dispatch consider any matter required by the message to be taken into consideration.

          The 10th Schedule of the Constitution contains what is popularly described as anti-defection law, in furtherance to Article 102 (2) and Article 191 (2) of Constitution of India. The provisions of the said Anti-defection Law contain an expression ‘Original Political Party’ to distinguish and prevent the members, except where such dissenting strength is 1/3rd of the total, donning distinct political badge. The said Schedule distinguishes defection from split in the political party. Split necessitates a collective decision of walk over by 1/3 rd of the members of a legislature party, while the questions of defection and split are in the exclusive domain of the jurisdiction of the speaker or Chairman of the House, the jurisdiction of the Courts is barred as per Para 7 of the said Schedule. However, in a catena of judicial pronouncements, the amenability of such decision of Chairman of Speaker is open to judicial review by Supreme Court under Article 136 of Constitution of India on various grounds falling within ‘Jurisdictional Errors’ AIR 1971 SC 1093, AIR 1993 SC 2120, AIR 1994 SC 1558.

          The fact remains that elected representatives to the Assembly read half-read and even misread the mandate in their own favour, as per their radical political perceptions, largely moulded by power-related aspirations. Such reading or mis-reading of the public mandate, often results in strategic regrouping inter se the elected representatives for the purpose of forming Government. The contentious interpretation of the public mandate are actually personal view of the political parties while it generates conflicts, turmoils and endless tactical maneuvers, which are necessarily not in consonance with what is judicially referred to as Constitutional Morality.

          In such critical power sharing exercises, attempt to usurp the Constitutional Morality and Constitutional Soul is conspicuously visible. The voter as a humble citizen feels cheated, robbed and pained – the commitments of good governance turn awry and wither away.

          In a recent election in Maharashtra, such power sharing exercises drove the Constitutional foundation of elected Government in a democracy, to an edge of a crisis. As the facts bear out, at the altar of power the ideologies of all political outfits stood sacrificed. It has become crystal clear that in the power games of democracy, ‘ideology’ of a political party is otiose being without any meaning or relevance. Ultimately, the governance is dragged by power sharing means and methods into a chaos and such political sin is justified by clever use of the expression ‘Common Minimum Programme’.

          In S.R. Bommai Case (Supra) emphasis was laid on ensuring that any interpretation (kindly read practice) of Article 356, must preserve and not subvert the essential features of Constitution, especially democracy and federalism. The subtle exercise of power by the President was peeped into by the Court, in a specific scenario where the party in power at centre was distinct from the parties staking claim to power in the States. The Court observed that expression ‘Otherwise’ occurring in the text of said Article is camouflaged by a political thicket. The said pronouncement of the Apex Court, answers the raison d’etre of the nocturnal journeys of the democracy as again witnessed in Maharashtra. Noticing a catena of earlier judgments and views of various eminent jurists, the Constitution Bench of nine Judges guided itself to the conclusions, which have become a beacon to the stranded ships of the power pirates in the choppy waters of the political sea of plural democracy in India.

          K.C. Wheare, an eminent Constitution Scholar, in his book Modern Constitution (1967 Edn.) stated:

          “The conventions not only give discretionary powers to the Government but also in executive governance and a legislature or executive relations, where such rules and practice operate. They may be found in other spheres of constitutional activities also.”

          He further stated that:   “A course of conduct may be persisted over a period of time and gradually attain first persuasive and then obligatory force. A convention may arise much more quickly than that. There may be an agreement among the people concerned to work in a particular way and to adopt a particular rule of conduct”. Sir W. Ivor Jennings had stated that: “The law provides only a framework; those who put the laws into operation give the framework a meaning and fill in the interstices. Those who take decisions create precedents which others tend to follow, and when they have been followed long enough they acquire the sanctity and the respectability of age. They not only are followed but they have to be followed.”

          The purpose of an observer in a floor test in a Legislative House is to save the sanctity of democracy which is the basic feature of our Constitution. The Supreme Court, being the sentinel on the qui vive of the Constitution is under the obligation to see that the democracy prevails and not gets hollowed by individuals. The directions which have been given on the last occasion, were singularly for the purpose of strengthening the democratic values and the constitutional norms. The collective trust in the legislature is founded on the bedrock of the constitutional trust. This is a case where one side even in the floor test does not trust the other and the other claims that there is no reason not to have the trust. Hence, there is the need and there is the necessity to have a neutral perceptionist to see that absolute objectivity is maintained when the voting takes place. Solely for the aforesaid purpose, the order is modified by directing that the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs who belongs to the cadre of the District Judge shall remain present to conduct the affairs with perceptible objectivity and singularity of purpose of neutrality along with the Secretary, Legislative Assembly. The order is modified accordingly. It has been so directed so that no party can raise a cavil with regard to the process of voting.

          The Courts have consistently maintained silence on the modality of confining and detaining the elected representatives before floor test. This practice, oft repeated, is indeed an anathema to civilized polity and negates the letter and spirit of democracy.

          As regards governance, the following well founded view expressed by H.M. Seervai in his Constitutional Law, Volume (2), 4th Edition, 2060 is relevant and sheds light on the subject.

          “18.57. The Constitution does not guarantee that power would be wisely exercised by the executive.- … But as long as the political atmosphere remains what it is, the Constitution cannot be worked as it was intended to be worked. It has been said that the Constitution confers power, but it does not guarantee that the power would be wisely exercised. It can be said equally that the Constitution confers power but it gives no guarantee that it will be worked by men of high character, capacity and integrity. If the Constitution is to be successfully worked, an attempt must be made to improve the political atmosphere and to lay down and enforce standards of conduct required for a successful working of our Constitution.”

          Another eminent jurist David Poland, Neil Parpworth and David Hughs in their Constitutional and Administrative Law dwelt on the responsibilities of the Ministers. Their following opinion carries weight in the context of appreciation of law:-

          “3. The Individual responsibility of Ministers

          The individual responsibility of ministers illustrates further Prof. Munro’s continuum theory. Ministers are individually accountable for their own private conduct, the general running of their departments and acts done, or omitted to be done, by their civil servants; responsibility in the first two cases is clearer than in others. A minister involved in sexual or financial scandals particularly those having implications for national security, is likely to have to resign because his activities will so attract the attention of the press that he will be no longer able to carry out departmental duties.”

          Identically in Constitutional Practice, a well received commentary by Rodney Brazier, the following well-considered opinion found favour with the Courts while interpreting the Constitutional Provisions:-

          “…a higher standard of private conduct is required of Ministers than of others in public life, a major reason for this today being that the popular press and the investigative journalism of its more serious rivals will make a wayward Minister’s continuance in office impossible.”

          Apart from the above, the dicta of Supreme Court in the following judgments deserves to be kept in mind, while considering the issues of power-sharing, power patterns and even governance within framework of Constitutional Scheme of democracy of India. 

          Having stated about the aspect of the constitutional morality, we presently proceed to deal with the doctrine of good governance. In A. Abdul Farook V. Municipal Council, Perambalur, the Court observed that: (SCC p.352)

          “The doctrine of good governance requires the Government to rise above their political interest and act only in the public interest and for the welfare of its people.”

          In Patangrao Kadam Vs. Prithviraj Sayajirao Yadav Deshmukh, the Court referring to the object of the provisions relating to corrupt practices, elucidated as follows: (SCC p.605, para 14)

          “14. ….Clean, efficient and benevolent administration are the essential features of good governance which in turn depends upon persons of competency and good character.”

          In M.J. Sivani V. State of Karnataka, it has been held that: (SCC pp.306-07, para 31)

          “31. …Fair play and natural justice are part of fair public administration; non-arbitrariness and absence of discrimination are hallmarks for good governance under the rule of law.”

          80. In State of Maharashtra V. Jalgaon Municipal Council, it has been ruled that: (SCC p.760, para 37)

          “37. … One of the principles of good governance in a democratic society is that smaller interest must always give way to larger public interest in case of conflict.”

          The events power games and ancillary and incidental occurrences in Maharashtra remind one of the magnum opus of George Orwell, titled Animal Farm. Without reciting the details and characters of the said famous prose, the following satirical chant in the said book deserves to be sung by the Beasts of India, nay, People of India to invoke grace of Divine for a better India, a Beautiful India.

“Beasts of England, Beasts of Ireland,
Beasts of every land and clime,
Hearken to my joyful tidings
Of the Golden future time.

Soon or late the day is coming,
Tyrant Man shall be o’erthrown,
And the fruitful fields of England
Shall be trod by beasts alone.

Rings shall vanish from our noses,
And the harness from our back,
Bit and spur shall rust forever,
Cruel whips no more shall crack.

Riches more than mind can picture,
Wheat and barley, oats and hay,
Clover, beans, and mangel-wurzels
Shall be ours upon that day.

Bright will shine the fields of England,
Purer shall its waters be,
Sweeter yet shall blow its breezes
On the day that sets us free.

For that day we all must labour,
Though we die before it break;
Cows and horses, geese and turkeys,
All must toil for freedom’s sake.

Beasts of England, Beasts of Ireland,
Beasts of every land and clime,
Hearken well, and spread my tidings
Of the Golden future time
”

May the sullied waters of democratic values get purer and cleaner with passage of time!

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free